Power Tools Lab is reader supported. When you buy through links on our site we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn More 

Which saw is better for your next project, a reciprocating saw or a circular saw? Both have their pros and cons, but one may be a better fit for your needs. Let’s explore the differences between these two powerful tools.

So, the question arises by many roots users is which saw is better for our next project a reciprocating or circular saw. But, before going further lets have a look on their pros and cons.

1- Reciprocating Saws

Pros: 

  • Both make quick work of materials like wood, metal, and even PVC. The reciprocating saw can even take on tougher materials like drywall and tile.
  • The key difference between the two is that the circular saw has a round blade and the reciprocating saw has a thin, narrow blade that moves back and forth.
  • The round blade of the circular saw makes it perfect for flush cuts that are straight across, while the thin blade of the reciprocating saw allows you to make quick work of flush cuts at awkward angles.

Cons:

  • The downside of this is that the reciprocating saw can’t make a complete circular cut, so you’ll have to finish the job with a jigsaw.
  • Reciprocating saws can be used one-handed, while circular saws require two hands. This makes the reciprocating saw a good choice for overhead jobs, while the circular saw isn’t.

2- Circular Saws

Pros:

  • Circular saws are much more powerful than reciprocating saws due to the fact that circular saw blades are larger and more rigid.
  • In many cases, a circular saw is powerful enough to cut through thick materials without a pilot hole.

Cons: 

  • Reciprocating saws on the other hand, have a smaller frame and lack the power of circular saws, so you’ll have to pre-drill a pilot hole.
  • This isn’t always necessary, as some reciprocating saws can be used with a firm grip to make light work of jobs like cutting up drywall.
  • A reciprocating saw also tends to be heavier than a circular saw, and many models lack the convenience of a dust bag.
  • Without the proper guard, circular saws can throw debris in your direction, something that isn’t possible with reciprocating saws.
  • For these reasons, circular saws are more popular with homeowners who need something to tackle smaller jobs around the house.
  • Reciprocating saws can be used one-handed, whereas circular saws require two hands. While this makes reciprocating saws safer to use overhead, circular saws are much more powerful.

When to Use a Reciprocating Saw:

  • For flush cuts at awkward angles
  • When a circular saw can’t be used
  • When you need a saw that can be used one handed
  • For overhead jobs
  • When you need a more powerful saw

When to Use a Circular Saw:

  • For straight cuts that are flush across
  • For thicker materials than a reciprocating saw can handle
  • For jobs that require two hands

Reciprocating Saw vs Circular Saw vs Jigsaw

The reciprocating saw is a popular choice for DIYers because it can be used one-handed and is more powerful than a jigsaw. It’s perfect for overhead jobs or jobs that require precision cuts. The circular saw is more powerful than the reciprocating saw and is ideal for thicker materials or straight cuts. The jigsaw is best for curves and intricate cuts.

So, which saw is right for you? Consider your needs and the materials you’ll be working with before making a purchase.

(i) Best Reciprocating Saws List

Reciprocating Saw vs Circular Saw

1. BLACK+DECKER Cordless Reciprocating Saw

Our Rating

4.5/5

Reciprocating Saw vs Circular Saw

2. Dewalt Cordless Reciprocating Saw

Our Rating

4.5/5

(ii) Best Circular Saws List

Reciprocating Saw vs Circular Saw

1. DEWALT 7-1/4-Inch Circular Saw

Our Rating

4.5/5

Reciprocating Saw vs Circular Saw

2. SKIL 15 Amp 7-1/4 Inch Circular Saw

Our Rating

4.5/5

1. BLACK+DECKER Cordless Reciprocating Saw

Reciprocating Saw vs Circular Saw

The BLACK+DECKER Reciprocating Saw is a powerful, lightweight saw that can make those tight cuts with ease.

It has a brushless motor to provide up to 2.5x more runtime to get the job done. This product has a long stroke and can deliver up to 2,900 strokes per minute.

The keyless lever-action 4-position blade clamp allows quick and easy blade changes in four directions for a variety of applications including flush cutting. This reciprocating saw also has a bright LED light to illuminate dark work areas.

Accessories included:

  • 20V MAX* XR Lithium-Ion Battery
  • Charger
  • Blade

Pros:

  • Lightweight and compact for easier maneuverability
  • Brushless motor provides up to 2.5x more runtime
  • 1-1/8-inch stroke length for fast and efficient cutting
  • Variable speed trigger for customizability
  • This is a tool that makes it easy to change blades. The blade can be changed in four directions and easily.

Cons:

  • Batteries not included
  • No case or bag included

Bottom line:

So, if you’re looking for a powerful saw that can deliver long-lasting performance and versatility, this is the right reciprocating saw for your next project.

2. Dewalt Cordless Reciprocating Saw

Reciprocating Saw vs Circular Saw

The Dewalt Reciprocating Saw is a tough tool for cutting. It has a powerful 2900 SPM motor and speeds that you can control.

This is a good thing. You can change the blade when you don’t need it. And you can make sure that the blade is always in the right position.

Pros:

  • Lightweight and easy to use, maximizing comfort
  • Tool-Free blade changes
  • Electric brake enhances control

Cons:

  • Ideal for medium scale projects only
  • A little underpowered in comparison to corded models

Bottom line:

This is a great reciprocating saw for homeowners and DIY enthusiasts looking to complete small projects.

The Dewalt Cordless Reciprocating Saw is lightweight, easy to use, and powerful it’s a great choice for all-purpose usage.

1. DEWALT 7-1/4-Inch Circular Saw

Reciprocating Saw vs Circular Saw

The DEWALT Circular Saw is one of the most powerful saws in its class (15 Amp, 8.8 lbs). The electric brake stops the blade after the trigger is released.

The bevel capacity is 57degree and the depth of cut capacity is 2-9/16-inch.

Accessories included:

  • Rip Fence
  • Blade Wrench
  • Dust Bag

Pros:

  • The saw is lightweight, making it easy to use.
  • The electric brake stops the blade quickly after release.
  • The bevel capacity is 57 degrees.
  • The depth of cut capacity is 2 9/16 inches.
  • Durable construction for long-term use.

Cons:

  • Some users have complained about the blade wobble.
  • There have been complaints about the lack of a laser guide.

Bottom line:

The DEWALT Circular Saw is a powerful saw that is lightweight and easy to use. The electric brake stops the blade quickly after release.

The bevel capacity is 57degree and the depth of cut capacity is 2-9/16-inch. The saw has durable construction for long-term use.

2. SKIL 15 Amp 7-1/4 Inch Circular Saw

Reciprocating Saw vs Circular Saw

The SKIL Circular Saw is the perfect product for those who are looking to buy a circular saw with advanced features.

The 15-Amp motor provides power and performance, fully capable of cutting through most types of lumber and sheet goods with ease.

The single-beam laser guides the cuts, while the integrated dust blower keeps the line of cut clean for better visibility.

The 51-degree bevel is a useful instrument for cutting. The spindle lock and on-tool wrench allow you to quickly exchange your blade.

Accessories included:

  • 7-1/4 in. Carbide-Tipped Blade
  • 16 oz. 3M Performance Surface Lifeguard Spray Lubricant, 98003
  • SKIL 2 Year Warranty Protection

Pros:

  • The powerful 15-amp motor delivers 5 300-RPM for greater speed and faster cuts
  • 7-1 4-inch carbide-tipped blade included.
  • There is a lock on the blade that can be turned to change it.
  • The saw can cut a bevel of 51°. It has a stop at 45° for a wide variety of cuts.
  • A dust blower is a tool that will keep the sawdust from blocking the line of cut. This means you can see better.
  • This lock is good for safety. It will not start the machine unless you press it, and it has a light that tells you if the machine is on or off.

Cons:

  • It may be too powerful for some users
  • No LED light to illuminate the cut line

Bottom line:

The SKIL Circular Saw is a great choice for those who are looking for a powerful saw with advanced features.

The 15-Amp motor provides plenty of power, while the single-beam laser guide and integrated dust blower make it easier to cut with precision and visibility.

The 51-degree bevel capacity and spindle lock also make blade changes easier. The only downside may be that the saw is too powerful for some users, and there is no LED light to illuminate the cut line.

 

FAQs

There is no definitive answer when it comes to whether a brushless circular saw is better than a regular circular saw. Both have their own advantages and disadvantages.

 

Brushless circular saws are more expensive than regular circular saws, but they offer several benefits. They have longer run times, they're more efficient, and they're easier to maintain. They also produce less heat, which can be important if you're working with certain materials.

 

However, brushless circular saws are not always necessary. If you don't need the extra benefits that they offer, a regular circular saw will work just fine for your needs.

Circular saw is the best for cutting hardwood.

Circular saws are designed to perform well when performing demolition work.

Reciprocating saws are used to cut tiles when a circular saw cannot be used.

Conclusion

There are many different saws to choose from, so consider your needs before buying one.

You may find that a circular saw is best for your next project.

If you want to make flush cuts at awkward angles, consider buying a reciprocating saw.

I Hope Reciprocating Saw vs Circular Saw Guide Will Serve as A Quick Reference. if You Like This Article Hit the Newsletter/subscribe Button to See Our New Posts About Tools and Share It with Your Friends, Also Gives Back Your Feedback if You Like or Dislike Anything in The Comments Section. 
Thank You.

Did I Miss Anything?

Now i'd like to hear from you:

Please let me know I miss anything Or Maybe I didn’t mention!

Leave a Comment

×

Table of Contents