Power Tools Lab is reader supported. When you buy through links on our site we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn More 

Which saw is right for your project? A scroll saw or a jigsaw? They both have their pros and cons, but which one should you choose for your next woodworking project?

In this blog post, we’ll discuss the differences between these two saws so you can make the best decision for your needs!!

so, the question arise by many roots users is which is better scroll saw or jigsaw?

I will answer it by the best manner. People are at different levels of woodworking they have different tools too. One is not better than the other they both have their own specifications.

Scroll Saw or Jigsaw, Which One to Choose?

They both have their pros and cons, but which one should you choose for your next woodworking project?

To answer this question, let’s take a look at the differences between these two saws.

Scrolling is an age-old technique that dates back to the Middle Ages when it was used to decorate and embellish the covers of books. Scroll saws were first invented in America during the 1840s, but it wasn’t until after World War I that they became very popular.

As the name implies, scroll saws are known for their ability to produce intricate designs on woodworking projects. This is due to their ability to do both straight cutting and intricate curves (like circles, ovals, and other shapes).

The Scroll Saw Is:

  • A very popular tool for craft projects. They are great at cutting intricate designs along the edge of wood in small projects, like these frames.
  • They also have a lot of small blades which can be quite inconvenient to change.
  • With a scroll saw, you’ll need to consider the fact that it doesn’t leave a very smooth surface on your project, because of all the little pieces of wood that get lodged between the blade and the raw wood.

This Is Why There Are so Many Jigsaw Puzzles out There!

  • Jigsaws are great for cutting curves and circles in larger projects. 
  • unlike a scroll saw, a jigsaw can’t cut along the edge of a piece of wood.
  • Using a jigsaw is also much faster than scrolling.
  • You can do a lot of woodworking in less time with a jigsaw, because of its rapid cutting action.
  • Jigsaws are perfect for cutting large pieces of wood with curved or straight edges.
  • This tool is very helpful for outdoor projects like the wooden birdhouse shown here.
  • It’s also great for cutting openings and holes in larger pieces of wood.

So Which Saw Should You Choose?

As we’ve discussed, both the scroll saw and the jigsaw have their pros and cons.

The Scroll Saw Is:

  • Great for small projects, like wooden clocks or picture frames, while a jigsaw is ideal for cutting the edges of larger pieces of wood.
  • Lastly, you’ll need to consider which type of saw leaves a smoother surface on your project.
  • Scroll saws leave a very rough cut on the surface of wood, while jigsaws leave a smoother finish with clean edges.
  • But don’t worry about it too much. You can make a scroll saw mimic the jigsaw by cutting from both sides of the wood, and then sanding down the rough edges!

So Which Saw Should You Choose?

As we’ve discussed, both the scroll saw and the jigsaw have their pros and cons.

The scroll saw is great for small projects, like wooden clocks or picture frames, while a jigsaw is ideal for cutting the edges of larger pieces of wood.

Lastly, you’ll need to consider which type of saw leaves a smoother surface on your project.

Scroll saws leave a very rough cut on the surface of wood, while jigsaws leave a smoother finish with clean edges.

But don’t worry about it too much. You can make a scroll saw mimic the jigsaw by cutting from both sides of the wood, and then sanding down the rough edges!

Answer It by The Best Manner.

People are at different levels of woodworking they have different tools too.

One can be suitable for one while not for another because different people work upon different level of projects that require different tools.

Speaking broadly scroll saw is better for small projects, while jigsaw is better for large projects.

Also Scroll saw leaves rough edges where as Jigsaw leaves smooth edges on the wood. It depends on the project to be done.

One can emulate another by cutting from both sides of wood and then sanding it down.

If you want the project to be smooth and neat it is better to use jigsaw and if you want a perfect wood work with small projects then scroll saw is the only option.

A- Scroll Saw Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Great choice for small projects
  • Provide a very smooth finish

Cons:

  • Tricky to operate
  • Blades can be dangerous if not handled properly

B- Jigsaw Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • A better choice for larger projects
  • More powerful

Cons:

  • Difficult to control
  • blades can be dangerous if not handled properly

(i) Best Jig Saws List

scroll saw vs jigsaw

BOSCH Jig Saws

Our Rating

4.5/5

scroll saw vs jigsaw

SKIL Corded Jig Saw

Our Rating

4.5/5

scroll saw vs jigsaw

DEWALT 20V MAX Jig Saw

Our Rating

4.5/5

(ii) Best Scroll Saws List

scroll saw vs jigsaw

WEN Two-Direction Variable Speed Scroll Saw

Our Rating

4.5/5

scroll saw vs jigsaw

DEWALT Scroll Saw

Our Rating

4.5/5

scroll saw vs jigsaw

Delta Scroll Saw

Our Rating

4.5/5

1. BOSCH Jigsaw

scroll saw vs jigsaw

The Bosch Jigsaw JS470E is a powerful saw that allows for precision cuts with its variable speed and 4 orbital action settings. It also features an easy-to-use blade change system and a button lock.

The Bosch Jigsaw is designed to handle tough jobs, making it ideal for those who work as craftsmen or contractors. Whether you’re working with hardwoods, steel, or counters, this jigsaw won’t let you down.

Accessories included:

  • Bosch Blade Clamp
  • Security Screws

Pros:

  • Variable speed for smooth cuts
  • 4 orbital action settings
  • Tool-less blade change system
  • Onboard bevel wrench
  • Ambidextrous lock-on button

Cons:

  • Sawdust build-up can be a problem
  • Limited to 3/8″ cutting depth on steel

Bottom line:

The Bosch JS470E is a powerful saw that offers a variety of features for precision cuts. With its variable speed, 4 orbital action settings, and easy-to-use blade change system, this saw can handle the toughest jobs.

While it may not be the best choice for those who work with steel, it’s an ideal saw for those who work with hardwoods.

2. SKIL Corded Jig Saw

scroll saw vs jigsaw

The SKIL Corded Jig Saw has many key features that make it an attractive product for woodworkers.

The electronic variable speed is great when you need to adjust speeds between projects, and the blade clamp makes for easy and efficient blade changes. On-board storage holds the wrench and dust blower.

Accessories included:

  • Blade Clamp
  • Work Light

Pros:

  • Electronic variable speed allows for a smooth cut across different materials and applications.
  • Speed control provides increased control of the saw.
  • Quick-adjust angled cutting allows for adjustable shoe bevel without the need for a tool.
  • Clear view precision gives a clear view of the piece being sawed so you can easily track the cutting line.
  • Easy blade change makes replacing blades a quick and easy process.

Cons:

  • The saw does not come with an on/off switch, so you have to unplug it to turn it off.
  • The saw is a little bit louder than other models on the market.

Bottom line:

Overall, the SKIL Corded Jig Saw is a great saw for woodworkers. It has many key features that make it a high-quality and efficient saw.

The only downside is that it’s a little bit louder than other models on the market.

3. DEWALT Jigsaw

scroll saw vs jigsaw

The Dewalt Jigsaw is the beast of all its forms, it comes with an innovative anti-slip comfort grip that is comfortable to use even in the longest of jobs.

It can be converted for use as a Dremel tool, scroll saw, hardwood jigsaw, etc., it’s the ultimate package.

Accessories included:

  • carrying case
  • blade-changing wrench
  • dust blower
  • T-shank jigsaw blades

Pros:

  • The Dewalt Jigsaw is incredibly versatile and can be used for a variety of applications.
  • It comes with a comfortable anti-slip grip that makes it easy to use for extended periods of time.
  • It has a variable speed setting that allows you to adjust the speed depending on the material you’re cutting.
  • The dust blower keeps the line of cut clear of chips, which minimizes cleanup time.
  • It comes with a number of accessories, including a carrying case, blade-changing wrench, and dust blower.

Cons:

  • The Dewalt Jigsaw is expensive compared to other jigsaws on the market.
  • It is heavier than many other jigsaws, which makes it difficult to use overhead.
  • It doesn’t have a rear exhaust port, which makes it difficult to use in dusty areas.

Bottom line:

The Dewalt Jigsaw is a powerful and versatile saw that is perfect for a variety of applications.

It comes with a comfortable anti-slip grip, a variable speed setting, and a number of accessories. It’s also the only jigsaw that accepts T-shank jigsaw blades, which gives you optimal holding power and professional results.

However, it is expensive compared to other jigsaws on the market and it is heavier than many other jigsaws. It also doesn’t have a rear exhaust port, which makes it difficult to use in dusty areas.

4. WEN Two-Direction Variable Speed Scroll Saw

scroll saw vs jigsaw

The WEN Scroll Saw is a very solid performer and perfect for those on a budget.

It has an innovative design that allows you to use different blades in two directions, giving you a lot more flexibility in your cuts.

It has a 16by11inch table that can be angled 45 degrees, and it can handle wood up to 2 inches thick.

Accessories included:

  • Hex key
  • Scroll saw blades (3)
  • Foot lock clamp
  • Dust port
  • Air pump
  • Onboard storage

Pros:

  • Inexpensive
  • Innovative design allows for different blades in two directions
  • Can be angled 45 degrees
  • Handles wood up to 2 inches thick

Cons:

  • Noisy
  • The table is a bit small

Bottom line:

The WEN Scroll Saw is a very good saw for the price. It has a unique design that allows you to use different blades in two directions, giving you a lot more flexibility in your cuts.

It can be angled 45 degrees, and it can handle wood up to 2 inches thick. The table is a bit small, but overall, this is a very solid saw.

5. DEWALT Scroll Saw

scroll saw vs jigsaw

The Dewalt Scroll Saw is great for precision cutouts and while it would not be ideal for larger projects, it is perfect for smaller pieces.

The controls are all very accessible and made the scroll saw easy to use for this reviewer. The price is also very reasonable so anyone looking to purchase a scroll saw should definitely consider it.

Accessories included:

  • Blade Clamps
  • Dust Blower
  • Variable Speed Controller

Pros:

  • Very affordable
  • Easy to use
  • Compact and lightweight
  • Cuts very accurately

Cons:

  • Cannot handle large projects
  • The motor is a bit noisy

Bottom line:

The bottom line is that the Dewalt Scroll Saw is a great saw for anyone looking for precision cuts. It’s easy to use and very affordable, and it cuts accurately and smoothly. The only downside is that it can’t handle large projects, and the motor is a bit noisy.

6. Delta Power Tools Scroll Saw

scroll saw vs jigsaw

The Delta Scroll Saw offers a strong, sturdy tabletop that can be used for all your cutting needs.

It has an electronic variable speed control dial that allows you to customize your cutting speed from anywhere from 400 – 1,750 strokes per minute.

With a dual parallel link arm system, this saw reduces vibration and produces clean, accurate cuts through the toughest materials.

A blade change lever makes for fast, easy blade changes, and with on-tool blade storage, you can organize your blades so you always have them when you need them.

Accessories included:

  • Blade storage area
  • Dust blower

Pros:

  • Variable speed control allows for a wide range of cuts
  • Dual parallel link arm system reduces vibration and produces clean cuts
  • Upper arm lifts and locks in raised position during blade changes
  • Tool-free blade clamp allows for quick, easy blade changes
  • On-tool blade storage area protects blades and keeps them organized

Cons:

  • Cannot make curves or intricate cuts
  • Motor is not as powerful as a jigsaw

Bottom line:

The Delta Scroll Saw is a great choice for anyone looking for a saw that can handle a wide variety of cutting applications.

It has an electronic variable speed control that allows you to adjust the speed to match the material you’re working with, and its dual parallel link arm system reduces vibration and produces clean, accurate cuts.

The upper arm lifts and locks in the raised position during blade changes, and the tool-free blade clamp makes for quick, easy blade changes.

The on-tool blade storage area keeps your blades organized and safe, and the dust blower helps keep your work area clean.

I Hope Scroll Saw vs Jigsaw Guide Will Serve as A Quick Reference. if You Like This Article Hit the Newsletter/subscribe Button to See Our New Posts About Tools and Share It with Your Friends, Also Gives Back Your Feedback if You Like or Dislike Anything in The Comments Section. 
Thank You.

Did I Miss Anything?

Now i'd like to hear from you:

Please let me know I miss anything Or Maybe I didn’t mention!

Leave a Comment

×

Table of Contents